Compare two industry-standard methods — the Multiplier Method and the Per Diem Method — side by side so you can see which approach yields more for your case and understand how insurers evaluate non-economic damages.
Fill in both methods and click Calculate to see which produces the higher estimate — and why that matters in negotiations.
Fill in both methods above and click Compare to see your side-by-side results.
⚠️ Estimate only — not legal advice. Attorney fees (typically 33–40%) are not deducted from this figure. Consult a licensed attorney before making any decisions.
Pain and suffering damages are non-economic — meaning there is no receipt or invoice to document them. Insurers routinely dispute, minimize, or deny these damages entirely. The multiplier and per diem methods are negotiating frameworks, not legal formulas. Some states cap non-economic damages in specific case types. Documenting your pain through medical records, a pain journal, and treating physician statements is critical to maximizing your recovery. These estimates are for educational purposes only and do not constitute legal advice.
The most widely used approach. Your total medical bills (the "special damages") are multiplied by a factor of 1.5× to 5× depending on injury severity, duration, and permanence. Low-impact whiplash might get 1.5×; spinal surgery with permanent effects might get 4–5×.
Assigns a specific dollar amount per day of suffering. Attorneys often anchor the daily rate to the plaintiff's daily wage — since that's what they'd pay someone to do their job while in pain. This method works best for shorter, severe injuries.
Insurance adjusters often use software (like Colossus) that effectively applies the multiplier method using their own internal factors — which tend to produce lower multipliers than attorneys would argue for. Knowing both methods strengthens your negotiating position.
Keep a daily pain journal describing your symptoms, limitations, emotional distress, and how the injury affects your daily life. Get your treating doctors to document your subjective complaints. Collect statements from family members who observe your suffering.
Gaps in medical treatment, social media posts showing physical activity, inconsistent symptom reports, pre-existing conditions, and failing to follow medical advice can all reduce or eliminate non-economic damages in negotiation or at trial.
Roughly 30 states cap non-economic damages in medical malpractice cases. A smaller number cap them in all PI cases. These caps directly limit how much the multiplier or per diem method can yield — your attorney needs to account for this in valuing your case.
Knowing which method yields more is just the starting point. An experienced personal injury attorney knows how to document and argue for maximum non-economic damages in your state.
Find a PI Attorney →